About
Public swimming pool charging admission and offering food.
Specific daily or average pool temperatures for the New Carlisle Pool are not publicly available. As a typical outdoor municipal pool, its water temperature would naturally fluctuate with ambient weather conditions and sun exposure, generally being unheated or minimally heated.
What are people saying (AI review summary)? Reviews for the pool are generally positive, highlighting its affordability, spaciousness, and welcoming 'small town vibe,' making it a popular spot for families. Staff and lifeguards are often praised. However, feedback on the manager, Ashley, is sharply divided; some commend her as amazing and helpful, while others strongly criticize her management style, citing issues like unstocked concessions, an impractical whole-pizza-only policy, and alleged retaliation against minor employees. Facility-wise, the pool is usually well-kept and clean, but specific concerns include slippery bathroom floors and occasional excessive debris in the pool water.
Location
Gallery
Amenities
-
Accepts Credit Cards
-
Accessible Entrance
Reviews
Listing Reviews
July 11th, 2025Lexi Parks
Ashley is running this pool into the ground. All she does is sit in her chair and write on her clip board. She can’t keep the concession stand stocked… and why the HELL would you only sell domino’s by the whole pizza? Sorry not sorry, but if I didn’t want it by the slice— I’d order my own pizza on the domino’s app??? Parents will make VALID complaints, and then to retaliate, the children of those parents get their hours cut? Why are you punishing your MINOR employees for concerns that their parents have? It just screams childish, and frankly, I don’t want to be a member of a place where such foolishness is in charge. She either needs to do better, or higher up management needs to fire her. This pool is an awesome place. The prices are great, it’s spacious, and up until this year… management was pretty on top of things. We cannot let this place get shut down because of one crappy manager!
August 11th, 2025Alicia Miller
I love this pool! It’s always been our go-to favorite! The new manager Ashley has been amazing, along with the rest of the staff! It’s affordable and has that small town vibe which I love! I have and will continue to recommend this pool to everyone.
June 20th, 2025Mike Brotato
Facilities are usually well kept. Pool has above average amounts of stuff floating even when not that busy, and the bathroom floors are so slippery that both my kids have wiped out in there. Othwrwise this is decent place for the family. There are sand volleyball and covered seating.
August 3rd, 2025Tiffany Byron
We celebrated our boys birthdays on an after hour pool party. I would highly recommend as the lifeguards were great and the manager Ashley ensured we had everything we needed.
August 24th, 2025Jennifer Moore
Love this community pool. Always clean and welcoming and the best kept town secret. Sad that season is ending. Superb summer 2025. Thanks so much.
Leave a review
Opening Hours
| Sunday | 12:00 – 7:00 PM |
|---|---|
| Monday | 12:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 12:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 12:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Thursday | 12:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Friday | 12:00 – 7:00 PM |
| Saturday | 12:00 – 7:00 PM |
Drop Us a Line